Open Menu Open Menu

    St. Thomas Law Review

    Evidence

    Criminal Justice SystemCriminal LawEvidenceMental Health

    When Madness Has a Method: What the Lindsay Clancy Trial Reveals About the Insanity Defense

    September 29, 2026By Gianelle Cabrera

    Few criminal defenses generate as much controversy as the insanity defense.[i]  To some, a verdict of not guilty by reason of insanity sounds like an escape from responsibility.[ii]  To others, punishing a person who could not understand the nature or wrongfulness of her actions undermines the basic principles upon which criminal liability rests.  Madness does […]

    Read More

    Artificial IntelligenceEvidenceFeaturedFlorida Law

    When Seeing Isn’t Believing: AI Deepfake Imaging and the Future of First-Party Property Insurance Fraud

    October 21, 2025By Laura Leyva Hevia

    First-party residential property insurance relies heavily on photographic evidence. When a homeowner experiences damage from a storm, fire or plumbing leak, the usual process is to file a claim, submit pictures of the damage and await inspection by an insurance adjuster. This pathway to collect evidence assumes that photos accurately capture real damage and that […]

    Read More

    Criminal ProcedureEvidenceFeaturedFirst Amendment

    Song or Statement? d4vd’s Lyrics vs the Law

    October 20, 2025By Nadia Jordan

    The recent public conversation flooding news and social media outlets around singer d4vd, highlights how quickly song lyrics can become entangled with criminal suspicion.[i]  David Anthony Burke, professionally known as d4vd, is an American singer and songwriter whose rise to fame was largely shaped by online culture.[ii] He first gained attention by creating Fortnite gameplay […]

    Read More

    Artificial IntelligenceEvidenceFeatured

    Justice May Be Blind, But AI Is Watching–and Quietly Reshaping the Legal Field

    September 24, 2025By Leyda Mujica

    The courtroom drama is no longer just human; Artificial Intelligence (“AI”) is writing, arguing, and even confusing the script. A trending story that caused outrage in the courtroom and memes on social media occurred in the New York State Supreme Court Appellate Division’s First Judicial Department earlier this year. Jerome Dewald, a plaintiff representing himself […]

    Read More

    Back to Top