Open Menu Open Menu

    St. Thomas Law Review

    Criminal Justice System

    Criminal Justice SystemCriminal LawEvidenceMental Health

    When Madness Has a Method: What the Lindsay Clancy Trial Reveals About the Insanity Defense

    September 29, 2026By Gianelle Cabrera

    Few criminal defenses generate as much controversy as the insanity defense.[i]  To some, a verdict of not guilty by reason of insanity sounds like an escape from responsibility.[ii]  To others, punishing a person who could not understand the nature or wrongfulness of her actions undermines the basic principles upon which criminal liability rests.  Madness does […]

    Read More

    Criminal Justice SystemFeaturedJudiciary

    Dreams and Judicial Nightmares: The Effects of External Influence on Judicial Conduct

    October 17, 2025By Hayley Grabowski

    Robert Rihmeek Williams, known professionally as Meek Mill, is a prominent rapper, songwriter, and activist.[i] His acclaimed song “Dreams and Nightmares” is closely linked with the Philadelphia Eagles, who stormed the field to the track during the 2018 Super Bowl, where they captured their first championship title.[ii] This song pays homage to Meek Mill’s hometown […]

    Read More

    Criminal Justice SystemCriminal LawFeaturedFlorida

    Balancing Florida’s War on Drugs with Constitutional Constraints

    March 29, 2022By Andrew Tuma-Waku

    On February 24, 2022, the Florida House voted and approved HB 95, which would make it easier for prosecutors to charge drug dealers with first-degree murder when a consumer suffers a fatal overdose.[i] This new bill was introduced to combat Florida’s ongoing war on drugs, as well as to deter drug dealers who “profit off […]

    Read More

    Constitutional LawCriminal Justice SystemFeatured

    Unplugging the Jury, Is It Possible?

    March 18, 2022By Massiel Alonso

    Is it possible to unplug a jury from the ubiquity of social media? I think not. When there is a criminal case with a newsworthy defendant, about 48% of Americans obtain information on the case almost instantaneously.[i] Notably, about 31% of the previously mentioned 48% of Americans rely on Facebook to deliver their news.[ii] The […]

    Read More

    Back to Top