Open Menu Open Menu

    St. Thomas Law Review

    Forum

    Criminal Justice SystemCriminal LawEvidenceMental Health

    When Madness Has a Method: What the Lindsay Clancy Trial Reveals About the Insanity Defense

    September 29, 2026By Gianelle Cabrera

    Few criminal defenses generate as much controversy as the insanity defense.[i]  To some, a verdict of not guilty by reason of insanity sounds like an escape from responsibility.[ii]  To others, punishing a person who could not understand the nature or wrongfulness of her actions undermines the basic principles upon which criminal liability rests.  Madness does […]

    Read More

    Employment LawFeaturedHealth CareMental Health

    Sleepless in Scrubs: Learning from Europe to Protect Patients and Physicians

    October 29, 2025By Sofia Ramirez

    Each year, escalating burnout and untreated depression drive more than 400 physicians to die by suicide.[i]  Before 1984, resident physicians often worked 90–100-hour work weeks with 24–36-hour on-call shifts.[ii]  Reform only gained traction after the highly publicized death of Liby Zion in 1984, whose care lied in the hands of sleep-deprived, overworked residents.[iii]  In response, […]

    Read More

    Criminal LawFeaturedFlorida LawMental Health

    A 911 Call for Help Shouldn’t Have to End in Tragedy: Addressing the Fatal Encounters Between Law Enforcement and Individuals with Disabilities

    April 18, 2024By Victoire Jonqua

      On Saturday, March 9th, 2024, Ryan Gainer, a fifteen-year-old Black boy with autism, was shot and killed by a San Bernardino police officer right in front of his family home in Apple Valley, Southern California.[i] Gainer’s family called 911 after he attacked his sister during a disagreement and broke a glass door.[ii] When the […]

    Read More

    Constitutional LawDeath PenaltyFeaturedFlorida Law

    Judge, Jury, and Executioner: Why Florida’s Proposal to Amend its Death Penalty Requirements Warrant a Renewed Discussion about its Mental Health System

    April 7, 2023By Mark Salnick

    In the United States, 27 states recognize the death penalty as a potential punishment for those convicted of a capital crime. Of those 27 states, Florida has recently been at the forefront of amending the requirements to sentence a defendant to death. Florida’s proposal to implement a supermajority standard for issuing a death sentence should […]

    Read More

    Back to Top