Open Menu Open Menu

    St. Thomas Law Review

    Forum

    Criminal Justice SystemCriminal LawEvidenceMental Health

    When Madness Has a Method: What the Lindsay Clancy Trial Reveals About the Insanity Defense

    September 29, 2026By Gianelle Cabrera

    Few criminal defenses generate as much controversy as the insanity defense.[i]  To some, a verdict of not guilty by reason of insanity sounds like an escape from responsibility.[ii]  To others, punishing a person who could not understand the nature or wrongfulness of her actions undermines the basic principles upon which criminal liability rests.  Madness does […]

    Read More

    FeaturedFlorida StatutesStatutory Interpretation

    Fully Autonomous and Fully Free from Criminal Culpability?: The Gaps of Florida Statute § 316.85

    September 22, 2025By Nathalie Tirado

    Technology continues to rapidly advance. As a result, vehicles with autonomous systems are more commonplace on Florida roadways. These autonomous vehicles (“AVs”) have systems that control everything: from steering, lane changing, to pedal control. In fact, soon, newer models will no longer require an individual to stay behind the wheel or keep attention on the […]

    Read More

    Criminal LawFeaturedJudiciary

    ‘No Way’ This Is Fair: The Fight for Mistrial and Recusal in Young Thug’s Trial

    October 15, 2024By Crystal Couso

    The ongoing trial of famous rapper Young Thug has been defined by dramatic confrontations between Young Thug’s attorney, Brian Steel (“Mr. Steel”), and the presiding Judge Ural Glanville (“Judge Glanville”).  In May 2022, Young Thug and twenty-seven others were charged with violating Georgia’s Racketeer Influenced and Corrupt Organizations Act (“RICO”).  Although several of the other […]

    Read More

    Criminal LawCriminal ProcedureFeaturedFourth Amendment

    Hard Times for Hill at the Hard Rock

    October 3, 2024By Kevin Nakfour

    The nation was stunned when videos surfaced on social media depicting Tyreek Hill, the star wide receiver for the Miami Dolphins—in handcuffs—outside the Hard Rock Stadium just hours before the Dolphins’ opening game on September 8, 2024. A routine traffic stop escalated into a tense confrontation.[i] When the Miami Police Department decided to release the […]

    Read More

    Back to Top